The Pretty Things' Defecting Grey arrives in the catalogue as a hinge: a single released in November 1967 that signals the group leaving its earlier R&B stance and stepping, deliberately and with attention, into the language of psychedelia and studio dramaturgy. Written by Phil May, Dick Taylor and Wally Waller, the track was issued as the band’s first release for EMI’s Columbia imprint after a period of transition, and it presented listeners with a form that stretched conventional single length and arrangement at the time.
From the first urgent guitar figure the record refuses straightforward classification as a three-minute pop item; instead it unfolds as a suite in miniature. The opening guitar—sharp, metallic and unembroidered—cuts into a mid-register vocal that keeps an intimacy even as the production widens. A repeated harmonic fragment acts as both anchor and hinge: it returns with variations, sometimes doubled, at other times allowed to hang as a faint echo under the drum pattern. That drum pattern is steady without being inert; it propels the tune forward while permitting the band to alternate between compressed verse episodes and more expansive, almost theatrical passages. The instrumental sections do not exist for ornament alone; they articulate shifts in mood and intention, moving the listener from a moment of near-conversational narrative into sections that suggest displacement and restless motion.
Lyrically the song sketches a figure—one of the so-called “greys”—who steps sideways from an expected life. The protagonist’s small gestures and the atmosphere of late-night streets and benches are rendered in concise lines that accumulate emotional pressure rather than explicit explanation. Phil May explained the subject succinctly: “Defecting Grey is about somebody who does the job. Grey suit, really. Somebody who suddenly realized that everything they’d lived for, and were brought up to believe in, possibly wasn’t right.” That plainspoken summation aligns with the way the vocal delivers the lines: at times close to spoken recitation, at times releasing into melodic inflection, so the words sound like an interior confession being refracted through instrumentation that both supports and contradicts them.
The production on the record mark a collaboration with a new guiding hand. The sessions that led into this period were overseen by Norman Smith, an engineer-producer whose recent work with other prominent British groups had already established him as someone comfortable with ambitious studio work; the band responded to his presence in the control room with both trust and offers of shared invention. Members of the group later described Smith as encouraging, practically becoming another member of the band during the sessions. “He actually encouraged us to go further and further,” one of the group’s guitarists (Dick Taylor) recalled of the sessions, a remark that helps explain the record’s willingness to stretch formal boundaries at the single stage.
Musically the arrangement balances economy with elaboration. Bass movements are often modal rather than tethered to conventional tonic-dominant motion, which lends the verses a circular sense—like a small boat drifting in a bay while wind and undertow rearrange position. Guitar timbres oscillate between brittle single-note stabs and fuller, chiming chords; these registers are mixed so that the lead guitar frequently sits at the same foreground as the voice, allowing melodic exchange more than strict hierarchy. Key changes are implied: the band moves between tonal centers in a way that reads as narrative modulation, a technique that makes the record feel like a condensed scene from a longer work rather than an isolated vignette.
There are multiple versions of the track in circulation—single edits and longer acetate or album-related takes—and the differences illuminate the band’s approach to space. The single edits favor immediacy, suiting radio’s constraints, while the longer takes allow additional interludes in which guitar lines thicken and the rhythm section breathes more expansively. Those expanded passages reveal an interest in how repetition and slight variation can produce a cumulative sensation of disorientation; motifs are repeated with small permutations that change emphasis, so what seemed straightforward in one verse attains new resonance by the third recurrence.
Although the record did not translate into chart success on release, it functions as a clear precursor to the group’s subsequent long-form work and to the album sessions that followed at EMI’s studios. The single was issued just as the band began the extended recording that produced their rock-opera material, and the sonic choices on Defecting Grey—the alternation of narrative vocal and extended instrumental sections, the acceptance of unconventional running time for a single—are connective tissue to that later project.
On a performance level, the interplay between voice and ensemble is notable for its calibrated restraint. The singer’s phrasing often lingers just behind the beat, generating a gentle lag that converts literal lines into suggestions; the result is that immediacy and distance coexist—the song feels both present and slightly removed. Harmonic support frequently opts for open-voiced chords, which leaves transient spaces for instrumental commentary: a guitar figure that answers a line, a snare that accents an emotional cadence.
Contemporaneous responses within the band’s circle were mixed. One industry figure reportedly thought the record risked their career because of its form and length, an observation that underscores how divergent the band’s step was from prevailing expectations of Freakbeat singles in 1967. Phil May remembered that reaction with frank amusement: “I mean, Brian (Morrison), when he heard Defecting Grey, thought we'd gone fuckin' mad. To him it was like career suicide.” That anecdote is useful because it shows the degree to which the band were consciously choosing audience recalibration over safe repetition; the recording embodies that choice, trading assured commercial mechanics for an expression that prioritized scene and mood.
You might also like following song from the Psychedelic Jukebox: "[1966] The Eyes - The Immediate Pleasure".
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.